Meet Our Staff

As our client, you will have a team of highly qualified professionals working for you to provide you with the best coverage for you, your family, or your business.  Building a long-lasting relationship with our clients is our number one priority.

Lee D. May

Lee D May

Owner / Producer

Lee D. May was born and raised in Washington, Indiana. He graduated from Washington High School with the Class of 1974. He attended Central Bible College in Springfield, Missouri and graduated in 1978. Lee and his wife, Kim, reside in Bloomfield, Indiana.

Lee began his insurance career selling Life Insurance through cold calls nearly 25 years ago. He is now Owner/Producer of Choice Insurance Agency, Inc. His “Choice project” began on November 1, 2002 and now includes locations in Linton, Bloomfield, and Bloomington.

In his spare time, Lee enjoys spending time with his family and friends, camping, traveling, and taking care of his tree farm. He is a member of the Bloomfield Rotary Club, Bloomfield and Linton Chamber of Commerce, and Bloomfield United Methodist Church.

Robin Neill

Robin Neill

CISR and Operations Manager

Robin Neill was born and raised in Fort Wayne, Indiana until she was in her teens and her family moved to the Bicknell area. She graduated from North Knox High School in 1982, and now resides in Linton. She obtained an Associates Degree in Business Administration in 1992. In 2012, she received her Bachelors Degree in Business Management with a minor in Accounting and Human Resources.

Robin began her insurance career in 1999 as a CSR. In 2002, she started working at Choice Insurance Agency with Lee May. She was the first employee. They had their first application signed on a cardboard box, because the desks had not arrived yet. She is now the Operations Manager. Robin holds her P&C and Life and Health licenses as well as having the CISR designation. Robin likes to spend time with her family, she loves to read, and she likes to do crafts when time allows. She is an extreme couponer, and she attends church at Mariah Creek Christian Church in Bicknell.

John Misz


John Misz was born and raised in Anderson, Indiana. He is a graduate of Anderson Madison Height High School, Class of 1978, and a graduate of Ball State University, Class of 1982. John and his family currently reside in Bloomington, Indiana.

John started his insurance career in 1983 as a Sales and Marketing trainee in Owatonna MN. He is now an Insurance Producer with Choice Insurance Agency. He enjoys helping people obtain the proper protection of their assets at a fair cost.

John likes to spend time with his wife and children. He likes to golf, do DIY projects, and travel.

Heidi Puckett

Heidi Puckett

Heidi Puckett was born in Fayetteville, NC and grew up on the outskirts of Fort Bragg, NC. She graduated high school from Cape Fear Christian Academy and from college at Ivy Tech State with a Digital Marketing Certificate.

Heidi now resides in Linton, Indiana. She is married to the love of her life Brandon and they have two sons, Avery and Ian. She loves crocheting, going on road trips and going to concerts. Heidi started her insurance career in September 2017 at Choice Insurance Agency. What she loves about being an agent is the people and being able to help them.